Knowing I need to update this little project, I thought about blogging about my resolution of Kindercare-gate, or about my affection for soy milk. Those are coming, but right now, I want to write about the past 10 minutes of Hardball with Chris Matthews.
Matthews has been hosting a panel including _____ Kennedy-Townsend, Ellen Moran, and Cecile Richards (Ann Richards' daughter) to talk about the election and women voters. While McCain likes to portray himself as a maverick and an independent mind, he is frighteningly backward on issues of women's health and other issues that are traditionally "important to women" (education, children's health, social services, avoiding nuclear war etc).
This panel was smart, interesting, and in-depth. They know what they are talking about. It seems that McCain has been on the opposite side of almost every issue that Planned Parenthood takes a position on since becoming a Senator. I usually like Matthews' sharp wit and unwillingness to let people get away with bullshit answers. Matthews did a decent job of moderating until one of the panelists (the Kennedy, I think) started talking about real memories of people that older women know who underwent illegal, dangerous, back alley abortions before Roe v. Wade. This conversation seemed to make Matthews uncomfortable; the lofty issues reduced to the graphic reality of what a world without Roe v. Wade was and would be like. Kennedy was right to frame the issue in this way, and it's really the only way to talk honestly about it.
The legal reasoning in Roe v. Wade is flawed. I remember the first time I read the whole opinion--my law school friends and I were dumbfounded to find that this dear and precious right to our own bodies was based on such tenuous reasoning. The penumbra in the Constitution. Oh, christ, we said to each other over blueberry pancakes, it's a shadow. And shadows can disappear just as easily as they appear.
But any woman over 45 or 50 has to remember the horror stories of what some women suffered and died before Roe v. Wade. Sometimes abortion seems like a passe issue--not as sexy as talking about relations with the Middle East or gay marriage, but this brief panel discussion reminded me of one of those basic rights that we may have come to take too much for granted.
How about a wire hanger on the door of every woman who is considering voting for McCain? Just a reminder...